PDA

View Full Version : album versions vs. radio remixes


wackyoverkhaki
02-09-2007, 05:43 AM
Gotta question: If Jewel remixes some of her songs, why doesn't she just record them the way she wants on the album? I know she rerecorded YYMFM and "Foolish Games" because she said she was pressured into singing in a way that made her feel uncomfortable and strained, but what's up with "Jupiter", "Break Me" and "This Way"? The album version of "This Way" actually sounded way better as well as more radio-friendly than the radio remix! The radio remix sucked in comparison.

So anyway, here are my opinions of her remixes, what do you think?:

You Were Meant For Me- The radio version is definitely my favorite, although I still like the album and Juan Patino versions. The JP one was very...interesting!

Foolish Games- I like the album version better- it sounds prettier. The radio version was ok, but sounded a bit too overproduced and some lines were even edited out to shorten it!

Jupiter- The radio version is ok, but I definitely prefer the acoustic album version by a long shot. So enchanting.

Break Me- I liked the remix the best and I think it did the song more justice; the album version was a bit bland.

This Way- like I said before, the album version is tops and the radio remix just plain sucks. She may have had more success with this single if she left it the way it was. I actually never heard "This Way" played on the radio but I listened to the remix and watched the video online.

Couple more questions: I own an import EP of Morning Song with two beautiful remixes- a "radio" mix and a reggae mix. I don't recall ever hearing "Morning Song" on the radio- was it played in Germany though?

Was "What's Simple Is True" actually a single that was played on the radio? I know there's a video for it and it's on the Ride With The Devil soundtrack, but I hear that there's a "radio remix" of it? Is that true because if my ears are right in the video the album version is played. And was this song actually on the radio because I never heard it. The only Spirit songs I've heard played on the radio are "Hands", "Down So Long", and "Jupiter". And was the live version of "Life Uncommon" just released on a CD single or was that played on the radio too?

Ah, so many questions;-D

Sitdogboy!
02-09-2007, 12:11 PM
the Jupiter single music was 10 TIMES better! When I heard it on the album I thought "meh", but when I saw the video! I loved the music! Ohhiohhh ohhhiohhh!

Was the What's Simple Is True music different? The music for thr radio was the same music for the video, correct?

wackyoverkhaki
02-10-2007, 12:30 AM
the Jupiter single music was 10 TIMES better! When I heard it on the album I thought "meh", but when I saw the video! I loved the music! Ohhiohhh ohhhiohhh!

I guess I'm in the minority here;-) And the video was awesome! Since you love the single (in case you don't already know this otherwise quit reading) it's available on this EP:
http://www.amazon.com/Jupiter-Swallow-Moon-Jewel/dp/B00000K0P1/sr=1-1/qid=1171066626/ref=sr_1_1/104-4912445-7346319?ie=UTF8&s=music

The EP also includes a beautiful live acoustic version of "Deep Water" and the song "Emily" (also on Phyllis Barnabee Finally Gets A Bra and the vinyl Pieces Of You). Jewel's EPs are great and definitely worth owning; I bought most of my EPs on Amazon. The prices fluctuate, so wait for a good deal.

Was the What's Simple Is True music different? The music for thr radio was the same music for the video, correct?

I never actually heard WSIT on the radio so I wouldn't know; that's why I was asking. But the one played in the video is definitely the album version. I just find it a little odd that there's a "radio remix" because usually if there's a radio remix then it's the same recording played in the video.

Sitdogboy!
02-10-2007, 09:37 AM
I really love Deep Water. Though, making love to a wall? I dont get that. Like a glory hole?

Break Me- I liked the remix the best and I think it did the song more justice; the album version was a bit bland.



Yes! I heard it live on the dvd and thought "This is a great song!". I didnt even notice it on the CD.

motoslam
02-10-2007, 06:15 PM
I like the radio version of Jupiter better, its more powerful in a way.

M€RIO
02-10-2007, 08:49 PM
The Radioedit of Whats simple is true is different!!!! There are guitars in the backround, percussion was added and the strings had more to come in that version. I love the jupiterradioedit its 100 times better than the albbumversion =) in my opinion.

nikos_
02-12-2007, 09:56 PM
You were meant for me: The radio version is MUCH BETTER !!!

and i love This Way radio version, i used to hate that song because i thought that it was boring but when i heard the radio version... i fell in love lol

ItBeThatWay27
02-13-2007, 02:38 AM
While I like how rock-ish the radio version of YWMFM is, I don't like the extraction of the "dreams last so long" verse... it annoys me that it's gone b/c that's one of my fav lines.

As far as the other remixes and edits, I'm not particularly moved by any of them accept that Jupiter is better than the album version (not that I don't enjoy the album version) I just like how enhanced it is on the radio version.
The only other remix I really love is the Pull Club Mix of Only One Too because it totally reconstructs the song (and I know I've already said this in about 20 other threads haha but oh well, it is an awesome remix)

never.alone
02-13-2007, 03:30 AM
i really really love one of the remixes of only one too but i dont know what its called sorry....
i havent really listen to the rest of the only one too remixes cos that was the only one that really caught me

ItBeThatWay27
02-13-2007, 03:33 AM
I also think the DJ Volume mix of Only One Too is awesome. Most people like the Lenny B Club Mix, maybe that's the one you heard Jessica?

spacedogpie
08-30-2009, 01:17 AM
No one will probably see this, but I'll give it a try. I'm looking for the Radio Remix of "This Way" (or a good quality vid) and have been looking for it for a long time. I have the radio remixes for some singles such as "Good Day" and "What's Simple Is True."
Thank you in advance to whoever helps me. :)
spacedogpie @ yahoo

ShawnShamrock
08-31-2009, 03:22 AM
[QUOTE=Sitdogboy!;17544]I really love Deep Water. Though, making love to a wall? I dont get that. Like a glory hole?


OMG I THOUGHT THE SAME THING!!!!

HA HA HA

On a side note I love all the radio remixes way better

Sitdogboy!
09-01-2009, 01:07 AM
I really love Deep Water. Though, making love to a wall? I dont get that. Like a glory hole?


OMG I THOUGHT THE SAME THING!!!!

HA HA HA

On a side note I love all the radio remixes way better


Oh my god, did I really say that! lol! xD I dont remember ever thinking that, but its hallarious, and totally something I would say :P

ShawnShamrock
09-01-2009, 04:24 AM
Then again who i sleeping where there are Glory Holes... Unless you are homeless!! Maybe there is all a deep connection after all

Sitdogboy!
09-01-2009, 12:06 PM
Hmmm.... maybe passed out in a public bathroom?

Could "Deep Water" be code for Bourbon? :P